When NOT to Pay Your NYC Traffic Ticket

New York City is a world apart when it comes to resolving traffic or speeding tickets. This is because the Traffic Violations Bureau (TVB), a division of the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles, does not engage in plea bargaining. Without plea bargaining, motorists who plead not guilty must fight their case at a full hearing, present evidence, cross-examine the police officer, etc. 

What makes this process even more difficult is that the TVB has all types of rules that make it easy for the police officer to win and hard for the motorist to win. For instance:

  • The TVB uses “clear and convincing” evidence rather than “beyond a reasonable doubt” as its burden of proof
  • The TVB does not permit any pre-hearing discovery
  • The judges are allowed to ask questions to help the police officer present his or her case clearly. 

All of these procedures make it even harder to beat your moving violation at a trial and may make it tempting to just pay the traffic ticket so that you can get on with your life. In fact, one could argue that these rules are designed to discourage contested hearings. However, there are instances when you should stand your ground and fight your ticket summons even if it seems to make sense to just pay the ticket. Sometimes, this will depend on your driving record, and other times depending on the specific alleged offense.

The stakes can be high, including placing your right to drive at stake when suspensions are possible, significant hikes in your auto insurance rates for 36 months, plus the cost of the ticket which roughly is between $45 and a whopping $600, and a possible Driver Responsibility Assessment Fee.

If you are looking for someone to appear for you so you can save your time and maximize your chances for success, please consider Weiss & Associate, PC.  Call us at 212-683-7373, or fill out our online form today! Read on for more information to help you decide whether you should fight your NYC traffic or speeding ticket.

Reasons To Fight a Traffic Ticket in NYC

While fighting a New York City ticket is an uphill battle, sometimes it is a fight you should pick. Admitting fault by paying some tickets can have severe consequences. These may include:  

  • A suspension of your driving privileges or license.
  • A traffic ticket may cause you to accumulate points against your driving record.
  • Having to pay additional fees related to the Driver Responsibility Assessment.
  • Having to pay mandatory surcharges in addition to the ticket and the related fees.
  • Receiving an increase in your car insurance premiums for 36 months.

All of these reasons are significant enough to fight for your rights. And if you decide to do so, it is crucial to remember that you have to file your plea within 15 days from the date of the alleged violation. Failing to do so exposes you to the TVB entering a default conviction, imposing a maximum fine, and possibly having your driver’s license suspended.

When NOT to Pay a Traffic Ticket in NYC

While it is difficult to beat traffic or speeding tickets in New York City, it is not impossible. The reasons to fight are set forth below. However, there are no hard and fast rules and the below is just intended as a guide. To get a more accurate assessment of whether you should fight your traffic ticket, feel free to email a photo of the front of your ticket to [email protected] and include your phone number. Or call us at 212-683-7373 for a free consultation.

1. The Ticket Is Serious or Your Have Other Tickets

When you are charged with what I called a “big” ticket (speeding 21+ mph over, reckless driving, leaving the scene of an accident, among others), then it is worth fighting in most instances. If you are convicted of a big traffic ticket, your insurance rates can be raised even if you have an otherwise clean record. Similarly, if you are convicted of a “small” ticket (any other moving violation), then your insurance rates cannot be raised unless you have already been convicted of a second “small” ticket. If you have 2 or more open tickets issued within the last 36 months (or 1 open ticket and one “small” ticket conviction both within the last 36 months), then you very well may want to fight your open traffic ticket(s) to try and avoid an insurance hike. Even with a clean record and a “small” ticket, you may want to fight your ticket for various reasons including if you are worried about getting future tickets, the open offense carries 4 or 5 points or you feel that you have a good defense.

2. The Ticket Has Errors and/or Omissions

When a police officer issues a traffic ticket, they are required to write the location of the offense, a description of the offense, the section of the Vehicle and Traffic law allegedly violated, the date of offense. Not as critical, but also required on the traffic ticket, are the correct make, model, and color of your vehicle, and license plate number. Therefore, before even considering paying for it, carefully review the information on your moving violation summon to ensure it is complete and accurate. Errors and omissions can be brought up at your hearing at the strategically best time to help you possibly beat your traffic ticket. Note that one or more errors alone do not guarantee that you will get your ticket dismissed. However, the existence of an error would encourage me to lean in favor of fighting it.

3. If There Was Something Wrong With a Traffic Sign

If you got pulled over for allegedly failing to comply with a traffic sign or speeding in a posted zone, and you have evidence that there was something wrong with the sign, such as defaced by graffiti, blocked by foliage, or misaligned or knocked down, you have a viable defense against the ticket. This can usually be proven by photographs and/or witness testimony.  Time and date stamped photographs taken close in time to the offense are the best evidence. For tickets involving disobeying a traffic control device, disobeying a stop sign, and exceeding the posted speed limit, the existence of a sign that is not clear and visible is a factor in favor of deciding to plead not guilty and fight your traffic ticket.

4. You Suspect There Was a Radar or Laser Error

Although police officers have speed radars, they are not error-proof. If they are not calibrated regularly, they may issue incorrect readings. In addition, other factors may result in unreliable determinations of speed. These may include vehicle interference, the position of the antenna, and radio interference. This is more likely to occur if you were near another vehicle at the time the radar was triggered. While this sounds difficult to prove, an experienced attorney knows which questions to ask the police officer to cast doubt in their testimony. Note, with laser or lidar devices, these arguments generally do not apply to fight your speeding ticket because they work differently.

5. You Have Evidence Disputing The Ticket

If you have a dashcam, you may have an accurate representation of what happened when you were pulled over. This can include a wide array of things, such as your driving speed, whether you were wearing a seat belt, whether you were using your cell phone while driving, whether you failed to yield, whether you ran a red light or whether you failed to move over to an emergency vehicle to name a few. Sometimes, events occur so fast, police officers can make honest mistakes — but video footage doesn’t lie. Strong, exculpatory video evidence is a factor in favor of fighting your ticket.

What happens at a traffic ticket hearing in NYC? 

When contesting a traffic ticket, you are required to follow the instructions printed on the ticket. This means entering a not guilty plea either online or by mail (we recommend doing so online at the TVB website). At the hearing, an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) will listen to the evidence presented by your lawyer, as well as to the sworn testimony from the police officer who pulled you over. Your lawyer will be given an opportunity to interrogate the police officer, as well as bring along any witnesses and present any additional evidence that may help you. The ALJ will then make a decision based on the evidence presented.

How a New York Traffic Ticket Lawyer Can Help

At Weiss & Associates, PC we take care of entering your plea as part of our reasonable flat fee. We also will re-scheduled your case and/or, of course, zealously and competently defend you at your hearing. Finally, we help you make your fine payment(s), if any, and get you a receipt for the outcome. All of these services are part of our reasonable flat fee. We can charge much less than lawyers that do not regularly fight traffic tickets because we pass along the savings that we can make by fighting 1,000s of traffic tickets per year. Another benefit of hiring us is that our experienced traffic lawyer will show up on your behalf, so you do not have to waste time in court.

Weiss & Associates, PC has extensive experience fighting traffic tickets in New York City and throughout New York State. We have a skilled team of lawyers who are ready to give you free advice on your available options. We will listen to the circumstances of your case and steer you in the right direction in your attempts to fight a traffic ticket. Call us at 212-683-7373, or fill out our online form today!

Previous Post
Fighting Your New York City DMV Virtual Hearing
Next Post
How To Handle Your First Speeding Ticket in New York

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.